Cracking Interview Question: “Why Should We Not Hire You?”

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pinterest

Table of Contents

Like open casting calls for your ideal part, job interviews serve as a platform for companies to find their next big talent. They throw blinders, such as the ultimate plot twist, “Why Should We Not Hire You?” 

In the world of interview questions, this one’s the headliner, a real showstopper. It’s like they’re asking you to reveal your backstage secrets, and knowing it could make or break your job game.

It’s the wild cousin of the classic “What’s Your Biggest Weakness?” question. 

But guess what? If you play your cards right, this is where you step into the spotlight, armed with a resume written by certified expert resume writer. Show off your self-awareness, drive to learn, and unwavering commitment to being the best. 

Why Your Weaknesses Matter for Employers

Before getting toward the answers to cater that most anticipated question, let’s face it. Have you ever wondered why interviewers throw curveball questions like “Why Should We Not Hire You?” or inquire about your weaknesses? Actually, it has nothing to do with the fact they don’t want to hire you, but it’s like a secret language of interviews, and here’s the scoop:

Picture this: Interviews are like a dating app for employers and candidates. They’re swiping right if you’re a match, but here’s the catch. They need to know you fit into their world – the job, the culture, the vibe. So, they’re all about discovering if your weaknesses are workable, ones that fuel your growth rather than stop you in your tracks.

And it’s not just about your flaws; it’s a test. They want to see how you handle the pressure, like when you’re hit with an unexpected curveball question. Can you think on your feet? Are you adaptable and resilient? That’s what they’re checking.

Here’s the juicy bit: They’re genuinely interested in your journey. They want to know what you think your biggest drawback is as a candidate because, here’s the secret: they prefer candidates who are self-motivated, eager to learn and grow from their setbacks.

So, why do they toss these curveballs? It’s a double play – they want the full picture, strengths and limitations, and they’re curious to see how you shine when you’re under pressure. So, it’s not about being “not for hire.” It’s about showing them why they should hire you, quirks and all.

One of the best ways to show them why you’re the perfect match is to have a resume that highlights your skills, achievements, and personality. A resume can make a great first impression, catch the attention of the hiring manager, and showcase your value and potential. You can also check out some top resume examples that showcase how to present your skills, achievements, and personality in a positive and professional way.

How to Prepare for the 'Why Should We Not Hire You?

Let’s take a closer look at how to prepare for the question, “Why Should We Not Hire You?

1. Research the Employer

Before the Interview, snoop around and gather intel about the company.

Check out job sites and forums to decode their culture and what they adore in a candidate.

For instance, if it’s a remote gig, you can say your solo work style might not be everyone’s cup of tea, but it’s your jam. That’s a win-win!

2. Choose Your Kryptonite

Admit a real weakness, but one you’re working on.

Weave in an anecdote where your weakness played a role and share how it’s your secret sauce.

If you’re fresh out of school, toss in an example from your student days.

Avoid fluff like “I work too hard” – they’ve seen that movie.

3. Shine with Strengths

When you drop your weakness bomb, make sure to sprinkle some strengths in there.

If your story’s about how your meticulousness led to overthinking, finish strong.

You can mention how that same attention to detail rocked another project.

Real-life, relevant examples make you unforgettable.

4. Practice Your Script

Once you’ve crafted your response, practice it out loud. You want to sound confident and natural, not like you’re reading from a script.

Share your response with a friend or mentor, and get their feedback. They might spot areas for improvement or suggest ways to make it even more compelling.

5. Show Your Enthusiasm

After you’ve tackled the weakness part, seal the deal with enthusiasm.

Express your genuine excitement about the role and how you’re eager to learn and grow within the company.

Let them see your passion – it’s infectious and makes you a standout candidate.

So, it’s not just about nailing the tough question; it’s about how to convince a company to hire you by showcasing yourself as the perfect match. Remember, it’s your time to shine and prove why they absolutely should hire you.

Examples of best possible answers to "Why should we not hire you?"

Why should we not hire you?” is probably what’s on your mind now. I’m going to give you a unique take on this well-known interview question, so go ahead and get some popcorn.

First and foremost, let’s address the elephant in the room: the reasons not to hire someone. 

Say, “See, if you’re searching for someone who simply punches in and out without enthusiasm for their work, you shouldn’t hire me. That’s obviously not who I am.”

But let’s flip the script because it’s all about convincing a company to recruit you, right? 

“This is my proposal: I’m not here to disappear into the background, so you should hire me. I am different because I am passionate, have new ideas, and have an unwavering desire to succeed. I’m not here to be “not for hire” – I’m here to change the game for you.”

Example 1: Social Media Manager Position

Although I love social media, I’ll be honest: I’m not the techiest person when it comes to the newest devices. Even now, I still use my dependable old smartphone, and I don’t always adopt the newest styles immediately. Here’s the thing, though: even while I might not be the first to discover a new app or filter, I bring to the table a deeper comprehension of social media strategy. My main goal is to produce material that genuinely engages readers and gets them to act. Therefore, I’m your best bet if you’re looking for someone who understands social media strategy from the ground up. When it makes sense for the company, I’ll also adjust to new technologies.”

Example 2: Data Analyst Position

As a perfectionist by nature, I might get bogged down in the minutiae of attempting to make every data point seem flawless. I might not be the best choice if you’re looking for someone to produce reports quickly and with little regard for accuracy. However, I do have a dedication to data integrity and accuracy that I bring to the table. Since I firmly think that the devil is in the details, my job is to make sure that the conclusions drawn from the data are solid. Therefore, if you’re looking for accuracy and solid analysis, I’m your guy.”

Example 3: Graphic Designer Position

“I’m not your normal designer who works 9 to 5. In fact, after the sun sets, that’s when I usually get most creative. Therefore, I might not be the best fit if you’re looking for a designer who is creatively charged at the beginning of the day. However, my work is the reason you should hire me. Late at night is when I create some of my most creative and visually striking designs. Even though I’m not the early bird, I’ll be first in line for exceptional, one-of-a-kind graphics that will distinguish your company. You need not search any farther if you’re looking for a designer who works well under the stars.”

Example 4: Project Manager Position

“I must confess that I’m not very good at meetings. I’m not your guy if you’re looking for someone who enjoys taking charge of and controlling meetings. But execution is where I really shine. It’s me who takes all those brilliant ideas that come up in meetings and makes them happen. Therefore, even if I might not be the star of your meetings, I’ll make sure that the projects that are discussed are carried out to the highest standard.”

Example 5: Sales Representative Position

“If you’re searching for a quiet, reserved person who spends their days behind a desk, you shouldn’t hire me. I get my best energy from interacting with others, both clients and coworkers. I know how to close transactions and create good relationships, but I’m also the kind of person that will talk you ear off. I’m your extroverted fit if you need someone who can convert small discussion into significant sales.”

Example 6: Software Developer Position

I’m a night owl when it comes to coding. I may not be a fan of the 9 to 5 workplace schedule because I tend to accomplish my best work in the late evening. I might not be the best fit if early-bird developers are given priority in your organization. What I do provide, though, is an unshakable dedication to writing well-written, effective, and clean code. Thus, I’m your man if you’re looking for a developer who will work through the night to produce amazing software.”

These answers highlight your advantages and distinctive traits while addressing the areas in which you might not conform to the norm. They demonstrate your self-awareness and your ability to provide the business with a unique viewpoint.

Tips For Answering "Why Should We Not Hire You?"

Here are some fresh tips for giving the best response to questions like “Why should we not hire you?”

1. Be Playfully Honest

Accept and be humorously honest about your peculiarities. Say, “Well, I’ll admit, I can get a bit carried away with my corny jokes in the office,” as an example of what you could say. But really, who doesn’t enjoy a good giggle while working? I swear, lunch breaks will be when I save the stand-up comedy.”

Be Personable

The key is relatability. Make a relatable comment that won’t hurt your prospects and that most people can understand. “To be honest, I’m not a morning person,” you might reply. More often than I’d like to confess, I’ve been known to press the snooze button. I’ve set several alarms, so don’t worry—I’ll be here bright and early every time.”

2. Highlight a Unique Strength

Change the question to highlight a quality that is valuable in this particular position but may not be appropriate for others. “Well, I tend to be a perfectionist, and it can drive some people crazy,” you might reply. But I believe it’s a superpower in this profession, where accuracy is essential.”

Demonstrate Room for Growth

Mention a shortcoming, but then follow up with how you’re actively trying to get better to help you get through this difficult question. For instance, “I sometimes struggle with public speaking, but I’ve been taking courses and practising, and I’m determined to become a confident communicator.”

3. Turn It into a Positive

Convert the bad to a constructive aspect. Try saying something like, “I sometimes tend to be too ambitious, which could result in working late.” However, I’m also quite committed, and I’ll do whatever it takes to finish the task, even if it means occasionally staying up late.”

Show Your Self-Awareness

Companies value self-awareness. You may say something like, “I used to be a bit of a control freak, but I’ve learned to trust my teammates and delegate.” I think it’s improved my ability to work with others.”

4. Own Your Uniqueness

Don’t be afraid to embrace what makes you unique. Say something along the lines of, “I love creative problem-solving. Even though it hasn’t always fit the mould, it has given my past roles new insights.”

Recall that the objective is to demonstrate your honesty, self-awareness, and flexibility. It’s important to project the image of someone who can accept their shortcomings and, when necessary, use them to their advantage. So, enjoy your individuality, maintain your self-assurance, and ace the Interview.


In conclusion – As for the best responses to the question, “Why should we not hire you?” they frequently sound like this: I may be somewhat of a perfectionist type person, or I’m too devoted to my work. However, let’s be honest; these clichés don’t work anymore. 

Rather, be blunt and say, “If you’re looking for someone who merely talks the talk without doing anything, you shouldn’t hire me. I’m the type of person who will make things happen and who truly lives the walk.”

“In a world where everyone is striving to fit in, I’m the square peg in the round hole – and that’s exactly why you should hire me. I offer a distinct viewpoint, endless enthusiasm, and a firm conviction in achieving goals. Why then shouldn’t you hire me? I will daily cause you to doubt that.”

Quick Questions

This question is a bit of a curveball, right? But it’s there for a good reason. Employers ask it to see how well you know yourself and if you can honestly admit to your weak points. They want to know if you’re humble and open to self-improvement and if you have a realistic view of your skills.

The secret here is to be self-assured and sincere. Recognize your true weakness and demonstrate that you’re actively addressing it. You might say, “I tend to struggle with time management, but I’ve been getting better at it by using various time management techniques.”

Absolutely! You should mention a genuine weakness, but make sure it’s not super critical for the job. And don’t just stop pointing out the problem. Talk about the steps you’re taking or plan to take to overcome that weakness.

The big no-nos include being way too hard on yourself and mentioning a weakness that’s a total deal-breaker for the job. Also, don’t dodge the question or try to sneak in a disguised strength as a weakness. Keep it real.

To get ready for this question, think about your weaknesses and pick one that’s relevant but not a showstopper. Create a response that tells a story, like how you’re working on it or what you’ve learned from it. Practice with a friend or mentor to get the hang of it. And remember, it’s not just about your weakness – highlight your strengths and why you’re a great fit for the job.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get A Resume that Access All HR Standards.